Red or Black? Should They Take The Money Back!?

September 8th, 2011

On the recent Wow – More Competition Controversies! blog, one of our users pointed out that all the issues highlighted were truly overshadowed by the controversy surrounding Red or Black? winner Nathan Hageman. Hageman was the first millionaire winner of the new Simon Cowell game show, however it transpires that he was allegedly jailed for beating up a woman (Sky News).

With his past exposed newspapers and politicians clamoured for the prize money to be taken off the winner. The Sun wanted to “Strip TV Brute Nathan Hageman of His Million and by all accounts it did seem that ITV investigated whether they could do such a thing.

However, Hageman gets to keep his money, much to the fury of Simon Cowell according to The Mirror. Hageman allegedly told researchers about his past and based on that they allowed him on to the show. It’s unclear whether he told them the full facts – and it was via that angle that they tried to strip him of his money (The Guardian).

However, legally ITV seem unable to budge. The issue after all is their fault. They allowed the contestant on to the show! The Mirror reports that programme organisers are tightening up their screening processes and have already dropped other contestants. No doubt to avoid further embarrassment.

The closest “similar case” we could think of was when Michael Carroll won £9.7m on the lotto. He picked up his cheque wearing an electronic tag. His win catapulted him into the tabloids – as did his subsequent splashing of the cash. Hageman would be wise to learn from Carroll and keep his head down.

All in all, there are many emotive points surrounding the Hageman case. Should the victim get a share of the money, as seemingly suggested by Cowell? Should former criminals be banned from TV game shows? Should former criminals be allowed to play the lottery? Should former criminals be banned from “winning” anything?

One thing’s for sure – the controversy has kept the game show on the front pages of the newspapers for a week!

What do you think? Leave your comment on the blog…

Related Posts
Is PrizeJar A Raffle Site?

Raffle sites or pay to enter competition sites have mushroomed up all over the place. These sites offer exciting prizes Read more

House Raffler Wins £100K In House Competition

The latest Raffall win a house competition to close has failed to create a new property winner. Win an Aylesbury Read more

Comping In The News Round-Up March 2021

Every now and then we like to delve into the online news archives and see if there are any interesting Read more

Is Your Facebook Winning Message A Scam?
Fraud Alert

After entering 100s of competitions on Facebook and Instagram you login one afternoon to discover a message in your DMs. Read more